Many U.S. Voters Support a Binding Nuclear Deal With Iran. That Might Not Count for Much

After months of agonizingly slow progress, talks in Vienna to restore the 2015 Iran nuclear deal made enormous strides last week, with negotiators at one point indicating they were on the cusp of a new deal. But the discussions have stalled again as the United States proves unable to commit to a binding agreement, and Tehran determined not to put itself at the mercy of another unilateral American withdrawal.

American voters, for their part, narrowly back a binding agreement, according to a newMorning Consult/Politico survey— but the difficulty of getting a formal treaty through the Senate puts the White House up against long odds.

On the numbers

• More than one-third of U.S. voters want a binding nuclear deal with Iran, which is nearly twice the share of the 20 percent who don’t want a deal. Another nonbinding agreement like the 2015 deal receives the least support, at 18 percent.
• Republicans were also more likely than not to support the deal, with 46 percent in favor and 36 percent against. Meanwhile, 41 percent of GOP voters said they wanted either a binding or nonbinding deal from the Vienna talks, compared to 35 percent who said the United States should not enter a deal.
• A clear majority of voters — at 53 percent — also said they supported the 2015 Iran deal, compared with only 24 percent who oppose it. That figure has fallen 3 percentage points since Dec. 2021, though the movement is within the surveys’ margins of error.

The big picture

It’s hard to overstate the impact of former President Donald Trump’s withdrawal from the 2015 Iran nuclear deal only three years after it went into effect. This was felt no more strongly than in Iranian domestic politics, where former President Hassan Rouhani and his moderate faction of the Islamic Republic were forced from power; hard-liners led by current President Ebrahim Raisi denounced them for not protecting Iran from the vicissitudes of American politics.

But now Raisi’s administration is getting a taste of the dilemma they criticized their predecessors for failing to overcome, as it struggles to extract guarantees from the American negotiating team to seal a new agreement. To maintain credibility at home, Raisi is seeking improbable guarantees that a Republican successor to Biden won’t repeat Trump’s withdrawal at the next opportunity. But with a split Senate it’s hard to see how Biden’s negotiators can ink any such deal.

American voters on balance support returning to a binding deal with Iran, but for any deal to be ratified as a formal treaty, it would need to pass a two-thirds majority in the Senate. That has made it virtually impossible to provide the Iranian negotiators in Vienna the promises they need to head back home to Tehran with their political reputations intact.

The question then becomes whether the prospect of sanctions relief is tempting enough for the Iranians to risk the ignominy of another U.S. withdrawal a few years down the line.

Thelatest surveywas conducted Feb. 12-13, 2022, among a representative sample of 2,005 registered U.S. voters, with an unweighted margin of error of +/-2 percentage points.